Carved Outta Stone
Carved Outta Stone
  • Видео 122
  • Просмотров 6 525 745
Predator 1987 - Muscle & Masculinity (Full Upload)
Massive thanks to viewers Stind, Vilgot, Armagan, and Илья_Леонид743☦ for supporting the original version of this video on my Buy Me A Coffee Page buymeacoffee.com/carvedstone/e/222191
I had to rip the guts out of my original work and add a funky filter for it to pass the dozen or so copyright hits the upload was incurring, but I thought the commentary was worth sharing to the wider audience.
The original can be viewed here for $2 AUD if you enjoyed it. buymeacoffee.com/carvedstone/e/222191
The full version of the previously released Predator analysis "intro". One of my favourite movies of all time, I explore the film's cultural impact, symbolism, and commentary on late 80s muscle and muscu...
Просмотров: 1 040

Видео

Interview With Keto Savage - Natural Pro Bodybuilder Robert Sikes
Просмотров 38521 день назад
Robert Syes (Keto Savage), a pro natural bodybuilder and author, discusses how he has successfully used a ketogenic diet for over 8 years to build muscle, get ultra-lean, and compete while remaining a natural athlete. He shares insights on optimizing keto/carnivore for bodybuilding, including training, supplementation, and peaking protocols. Check out Rob's socials - Webpage - ketosavage.com/ R...
Jamie Lewis & Food Historian Greta Hardin - The Fascinating History Of Food & Lifting
Просмотров 745Месяц назад
This episode joins Jamie Lewis and food historian, Greta Hardin as they dive into the fascinating world of food history and its impact on human civilization (and lifting!). From the rise of agriculture to the future of lab-grown meat, they explore the surprising ways in which our diets have evolved over time. Along the way, they debunk common myths about historical eating habits and reveal how ...
Phil Heath's Breaking Olympia - My Review
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.Месяц назад
My review of the recently recleased "Breaking Olympia" - a captivating 2-hour documentary that delves into the complicated career of one of professional bodybuilding's most controversial figures, Phil Heath ﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀ Thank you for supporting my work: If you like what I do, how about shouting me a coffee! ☕www.buymeacoffee.com/carvedstone I also do online coaching ! 💪 ╰┈➤DM for co...
Battle Of The Amateurs - Joel Kellet & Brock Waugh Documentary Review
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.2 месяца назад
A review of the recently released documentary, "Battle Of The Amateurs" featuring Aussie natural bodybuilders, Joel Kellet & Brock Waugh. In the enduring spirit of the Golden Era, I review Joel & Brock's humourous and informative journey to the competitive bodybuilding stage. Check out "Battle Of The Amateurs Here" - shorturl.at/uIKOX ﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀﹀ Thank you for supporting my work: I...
Gregg Valentino Interview
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.2 месяца назад
Gregg Valentino Interview
Gregg Valentino Reacts: The Seven Deadly Sins of 90s Bodybuilders
Просмотров 2,1 тыс.2 месяца назад
Gregg Valentino Reacts: The Seven Deadly Sins of 90s Bodybuilders
The Seven Deadly Sins Of 90s Bodybuilding
Просмотров 5 тыс.3 месяца назад
The Seven Deadly Sins Of 90s Bodybuilding
Lyle McDonald Interview - Unravelling Fitness Industry B.S. & Decoding The Gurus
Просмотров 4,2 тыс.3 месяца назад
Lyle McDonald Interview - Unravelling Fitness Industry B.S. & Decoding The Gurus
Dr Conor Heffernan & Jamie Lewis - Unveiling Lost Secrets of Lifting Culture
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.3 месяца назад
Dr Conor Heffernan & Jamie Lewis - Unveiling Lost Secrets of Lifting Culture
SAVAGE Arnold Destroys Woman On Live TV - The Backstory
Просмотров 5 тыс.4 месяца назад
SAVAGE Arnold Destroys Woman On Live TV - The Backstory
Tony Pearson & Andrew Menjivar - Driven - The Interview
Просмотров 3204 месяца назад
Tony Pearson & Andrew Menjivar - Driven - The Interview
Predator 1987 - Muscle & Masculinity
Просмотров 9204 месяца назад
Predator 1987 - Muscle & Masculinity
Interview With Ed Connors - Stories From The Golden Era!
Просмотров 7644 месяца назад
Interview With Ed Connors - Stories From The Golden Era!
The Three Muscleteers - Ed Connors & Gold's Gym Legacy - My Review
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.4 месяца назад
The Three Muscleteers - Ed Connors & Gold's Gym Legacy - My Review
SEX LIES MUSCLE - Guess Who?
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.5 месяцев назад
SEX LIES MUSCLE - Guess Who?
John Little & Randy Roach Interview - The Real Fights Of Bruce Lee
Просмотров 6 тыс.5 месяцев назад
John Little & Randy Roach Interview - The Real Fights Of Bruce Lee
Serge Nubret Pump Training - My Experience
Просмотров 20 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Serge Nubret Pump Training - My Experience
Børge Fagerli Interview - Training, TRT and "The Last Program"
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Børge Fagerli Interview - Training, TRT and "The Last Program"
Driven - The Tony Pearson Story - My Review
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Driven - The Tony Pearson Story - My Review
Jamie Lewis Interview - The Man, The Meth, The History
Просмотров 3,8 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Jamie Lewis Interview - The Man, The Meth, The History
Channel Update - Looking Back While Moving Forward
Просмотров 6335 месяцев назад
Channel Update - Looking Back While Moving Forward
Lee Priest - Napoleon Complex Or Underrated Superman?
Просмотров 3,7 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Lee Priest - Napoleon Complex Or Underrated Superman?
Dream Big Out-Takes - Golden Era History With Marc Martinez
Просмотров 8006 месяцев назад
Dream Big Out-Takes - Golden Era History With Marc Martinez
Pumping Iron, Politics and PED's! Louis Theroux's Extreme Bodybuilding: My Review Part 2
Просмотров 14 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Pumping Iron, Politics and PED's! Louis Theroux's Extreme Bodybuilding: My Review Part 2
Steroids, Schmoes & Sweaty-Underpants! Louis Theroux's Extreme Bodybuilding - My Review
Просмотров 3,8 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Steroids, Schmoes & Sweaty-Underpants! Louis Theroux's Extreme Bodybuilding - My Review
Bob Paris Gorilla Suit -Bodybuilding Pioneer or Paris-ite
Просмотров 65 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Bob Paris Gorilla Suit -Bodybuilding Pioneer or Paris-ite
Muscle Smoke & Mirrors Author Randy Roach
Просмотров 2,9 тыс.7 месяцев назад
Muscle Smoke & Mirrors Author Randy Roach
Arnold's "Be Useful: 7 Tools For Life" - A Brutally Honest Book Review #arnoldschwarzenegger
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Arnold's "Be Useful: 7 Tools For Life" - A Brutally Honest Book Review #arnoldschwarzenegger
A Picture Of Dorian Yates #dorianyates
Просмотров 24 тыс.9 месяцев назад
A Picture Of Dorian Yates #dorianyates

Комментарии

  • @gregbutson7842
    @gregbutson7842 8 часов назад

    I like how Jamie takes the time to mute his mic before he coughs. I wish people on other podcasts had this kind of self awareness. Great show guys!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 2 часа назад

      Obnoxious amounts of unstifled laughter, people that bring a plate of food onto their show, or slurp their coffee while talking. Yeah, the podcast landscape runs the gamut of degenerates who can't decipher simple rules of etiquette. JL might be abrasive, but he's definitely a gentleman 😃 Cheers for watching mate

  • @WarriorSidMentzer
    @WarriorSidMentzer 9 часов назад

    John and Pete at least tried to make a difference...

  • @cuchulainn1967
    @cuchulainn1967 17 часов назад

    What about Bill Pettis for best arms?!?!

  • @Noone-fs5qx
    @Noone-fs5qx 19 часов назад

    Another amazing episode! Also, I about fell off my chair when Jamie mentioned his paypal. LOL

  • @stevepace-first8617
    @stevepace-first8617 21 час назад

    Here we get a contrary opinion. ruclips.net/video/i8FiXHAk0ow/видео.html a professor saying cardio is bad for you. so what is the reality here, train all day or a few minutes once or twice a week, crossfit all day or HIT deadlift and dips once a fortnight. If things were what they seem to be, there would be no need for science, and here we have scientists/medical professionals defending diametrically opposing positions while we scratch our heads.

    • @comment_deleted
      @comment_deleted 15 часов назад

      Do zero cardio for a couple years and see how you feel. I did zero cardio for 3 years and it was one of the dumbest things I’ve ever done. I feel like shit and getting back to where I used to be is incredibly difficult.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 10 часов назад

      Bart's got some contrarian takes for sure. That's one of the weirder ones, but we'll review that vid next next week on my other show with Craig

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 Час назад

      @@carvedouttastone Brillianr! I keep saying the same, I have no formal training in the fitness/ nutrients field and it seems that every year or so there is some new massive solution and immediately the diametrically opposing perspective is voiced, all backed up by science if we are to believe the various proponents. It seems that those with big brass balls to express themselves in convincing terms gain an audience but then the next big thing comes out and the merry go round continues. The exact same person who so adamantly sets out their case, replete with expletives and insults of those who hold a contrary view, suddenly confesses all and set out another equally absolutist case. Maybe Jamie comes under this umbrella. The whole thing is a sea of confusion, chaos, contradiction. Make almost any statement you like and there is no way to prove or disprove it. Yet there is no avoiding making a choice, even if that choice is Doritos and Netflix as we speed up the process to answering the question of what happens when we die… Anyway, keep up the good work, at least it provokes thought.

  • @stevepace-first8617
    @stevepace-first8617 День назад

    The VO2 max q…maybe some of you have heard of Peter Attia MD, he wrote “Outlive”. He says of all the metrics, VO2 is most highly correlated with longevity. So important stuff. The protocol he advocates is the one mentioned in this discussion, the 4x4. So you warm up and then you do zone 5 for 4 mins. For most of us the only practical way to do this is via heart rate monitor. You need to be at 95% plus of max heart rate. I do it by hill running. Then 4 mins recovery, I walk down the hill. A grand total of 4 reps, then cool down. Once a week is enough. This is hard, hard work. Recently I have been doing it with a skipping rope and kettlebells, same heart rate idea. I find it less problematic in terms of soreness and recovery. Attia recommends that we do the bulk of our cardio in zone 2, so 60-70% of max. This is easy. I can jog but for many, jogging is too hard to stay in this zone. Jog walk may be required. He advises against the middle ground. It’s a lot of zone 2, a little zone 5, and strength training and some other stuff he calls stability.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      I read Outlive, but for the most part I can't stand Attila's schtick. It's like he recycles 3 year old reddit threads and turns them into books and podcast content. Craig this week sent me a "stunning" new Attia "bleeding-edge discovery" regarding pinning one's TRT across the week using micro dosing to minimize estrogen side effects....uhhh yeah, this is what Bodybuilders have already been doing for the last decade or so...same goes with the "revelation" regarding vo2 max and longevity - I really can't see how or why this is so revolutionary? The guy is another grifter in the same vein as Huberman etc and is so often wrong in his pronouncements, it borders on parody

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      To your point it sounds like a good program you've got there, but I've found doing a very physically active job for 8 hours a day trumps any cardio program I've done before :-)

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 23 часа назад

      @@carvedouttastone I don’t do the TRT stuff and no doubt you are right in saying he is cashing in, one of many. But the advice to be aware of VO2 and how to up it, regardless of source, seems, as far as I can tell, prudent, In this game we are tossed around by all the contradictory voices, charismatic figures, phd waving nerds, magnificent athletes, and working out the truth is often a lucky shot. Pin the tail on the donkey. Carnivore? Hit? Zone 2? Vo2 max? Grip? Fenugreek? Dianabol …It goes on and on and we have to choose, even if the choice is sedentary living, as seems to be the majority decision.

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 22 часа назад

      @@carvedouttastone yes, I have worked as a labourer to bricklayers and a few heavy factory jobs and I did minimum training beyond that. I found them to be simply too much to be beneficial, just exhausting and I doubt they contribute to longevity. But maybe they do if you live clean and eat well.

  • @stevepace-first8617
    @stevepace-first8617 День назад

    I recently heard this “60 is when youth starts”. Ok, think about it…at a certain point the posing and the massive lifts become irrelevant. What you need is not to die or be an invalid. You need to fight ageing. Now of course, if you have done nothing for 6 decades, bad start, but maybe the thing is, at some point, you need to think it terms of health and longevity and the rest is increasingly irrelevant.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      But Craig on the other podcast I do is 60 and he's still going strong - competing and doing the big lifts. The guy is fkn strong and trains Dorian style like a beast and maintains a lifelong natty status! You don't have to resign yourself to disbanding the entire game we fell in love with just to preserve the remaining years.in the interest of longevity. I for one won't be going gentle into that good night, that's for fkn sure 😊

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 22 часа назад

      @@carvedouttastone We all decide. My thought as an amateur is that I need to dedicate a lot of attention to cardiorespiratory fitness and again, as far as I can tell, calorie restriction is a good idea. So maybe like Craig, and I have written this before, I am opting for HIT ( doggcrapp at the moment) and lots of cardio. I do not know for sure this is the way, as I said, I was influenced by Attia, but who knows, maybe all that cardio is a very bad idea as some, again with scientific credentials, maintain, including many in the HIT space. Maybe the idea of HIT as an old age protocol is worth a thought.

  • @andrewwelch1040
    @andrewwelch1040 День назад

    John Terilli came second to Lee Haney in 1983 at the Pro World Cup, apparently only one point in it. I personally thought John had a better Physique, like a bigger more complete Zane.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      2nd to Haney is definitely a feather in the cap for John. I wish they still made physiques like that, but alas, we won't be seeing them any longer

    • @andrewwelch1040
      @andrewwelch1040 День назад

      @@carvedouttastone insulin and growth make everyone look the same with bodies that look like bloated pigs.

  • @johnconner1061
    @johnconner1061 День назад

    Thanks for the podcast & hardwork Shawn & Jamie . Very informative keep going 👊👍

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      You're welcome mate. I love doing these and am willing to keep them going as long as Jamie wants to show up and chat shop

  • @MasonMoore-fz7fy
    @MasonMoore-fz7fy День назад

    So how did you gain weight when you gave up cream?

  • @MarkIsralls
    @MarkIsralls День назад

    Reg Park was 100% natural, grew up around him my dad was his mate He actually stopped competing because of the peds influence in bodybuilding

  • @goldenwarrior5664
    @goldenwarrior5664 День назад

    2000 set ups a DAY

  • @timmyasikin4177
    @timmyasikin4177 День назад

    Mix video...true lies....!!!

  • @nathanpearl2321
    @nathanpearl2321 День назад

    Randy's Muscle, Smoke, and Mirrors books have sections about Rheo H. Blair, the REAL nutritional program most of the big guys were using until around 1979.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone День назад

      Randy's books are my Bibles. Would you like to see another discussion with Randy? If so, any topics you'd like me to raise with him? Thanks for your comment

  • @Be_An_Esther
    @Be_An_Esther 2 дня назад

    Well his dad was a literal n_zi soldier so... Fruit don't fall far from the tree.

  • @BigV24
    @BigV24 2 дня назад

    Glad you ended up seeing that article Shawn. Craig and yourself made some great points about that and the current "testosterone crisis" (I wonder which crisis is next after this). There's a lot of grifting going on. I did not consider that supplementation is necessary as you age so kudus for expanding my perspective there. It's worrying to see young lifters be so infatuated with T levels and using it as an excuse to hop on the gear. I'm also a regular watcher of Natural Hypertrophy and couldn't agree with you both that the best approach to lifting is borrowing elements from both schools of thought to maximise the gym-going experience and gains. I'm also glad that someone else can't stand Mike Isratael's lame gimmick. Had to stop watching with the forced (cringe) comedic jokes he would insert after every two-three sentences.

    • @craigwinter458
      @craigwinter458 2 дня назад

      Cheers for your comment, Big V 🙏😊 The hormonal pathways are very complex and difficult to treat. So a multi-pronged, holistic approach in improving lifestyle habits and overall health should be trialled first, before going straight to TRT.

  • @shaundouglas2057
    @shaundouglas2057 3 дня назад

    Arrogance is often associated with stupidity.

  • @stind1299
    @stind1299 3 дня назад

    Really enjoyable episode. It is ridiculous to suggest the York lifters were HIT practitioners. Jamie has the truth from historical research but also consider from a practical safety standpoint. They were lifters who used free weights and to do a weighted Squat to failure is stupid as you put yourself in position to seriously hurt yourself. I mean on a leg press you could work to failure and survive. (I wonder if Dorian's injury while squatting was due to such a stupid mentality. He then used the leg press successfully.) Unless I'm mistaken the York lifters did not advocate things like forced reps and preferred to demonstrate independence, dominance and mastery over the weights. If Steve Stanko was pulling over a substantial weight to bench, I can't see Grimek or another Yiork lifter being any different. They were lifters for the long haul. Why risk hurting youself and stop making progress on the thing you love? A contemporary such as Bill Pearl illustrates the same mentality. Except from an article on his heavy training. He’d do a full-body workout routine for developing power on Monday, Wednesday, and Fri, then he’d rest the other four days out of the week. Before the working sets, he’d 1-2 warmup sets and then would use 75-90% of his one-rep max for each lift. He rests 2-3+ minutes between sets. Pearl didn’t train to failure with this routine; he’d stop when the reps began to slow down. Seems like a sensible thing to do with his poundages. Part of the reason HIT is popular I think because of the gym machine culture.They are built with safety in mind. You can safely work to failure without weights crashing down on you. It may be worth exploring how Gyms have changed since the 50s and the impact it has had. I remember hearing about 'Doug's Gym' in Texas where nothing had changed since the 60s. Same equipment and certainly no air conditioning. A time capsule from its time.Even Leo Stern's Gym when Bill Pearl first entered it or Draper's Dungeon style Gym based in a Cellar where he was happiest.

  • @nathanpearl2321
    @nathanpearl2321 3 дня назад

    When I trained HIT style, I actually don't know how well it worked for muscle building because I stayed hurt all the time on those programs. And before anyone says it: I DID use proper form, I DID warm up, and I DID train slowly. But I stayed hurt all the time, primarily my shoulders, but also all kinds of muscle pulls and strains, etc.

  • @lissadawes4243
    @lissadawes4243 4 дня назад

    This Arnold would beat up new and unimproved Arnold today.

  • @larryholliday8412
    @larryholliday8412 4 дня назад

    Thanks for this video.

  • @videogamer8564
    @videogamer8564 4 дня назад

    Lol

  • @cuchulainn1967
    @cuchulainn1967 4 дня назад

    @ 4:13min " Good riddens to both of them..."?!?! Jamie, for a smart dude you act like a r*tarded dick. What makes you so miserable and self- hating?

  • @pujaram6151
    @pujaram6151 4 дня назад

    #rnoldschwarzenegger Arnold 💪 with Arnold.....on

  • @michiel5160
    @michiel5160 4 дня назад

    I don't know if he knows about neck traction, but it might help. I also think there is not a lot of reason to do neck bridges if you don't wrestle. Neck harness will build your neck better.

  • @scottyhamilton1381
    @scottyhamilton1381 5 дней назад

    4 months in- never going back.Wish I knew about this 20 years ago. Lost 8kg in the first 3 weeks and have since lost another 7kg,yet the best part is an 80% reduction in joint pain/inflammation. My wife's rheumatoid arthritis disappeared within 2 weeks. We just 'cheated' with mushrooms,chilli and garlic in a slow cooked brisket yet felt fine and will certainly limit that... Better sleep,mental clarity,happier within... Bacon,eggs,skin on salmon with a few prawns,chicken wings,lamb,a plethora of beef choices,and BUTTER is what works for us... Oxylate dumping had my eyes 'grainy' for a few days 2 months in but quickly passed... We're spreading the word for friends to at least try it for 30 days... Keep up the content brother!!!

  • @MultiTsbaby
    @MultiTsbaby 7 дней назад

    Loved it Shawn. Cheers mate

  • @houseofsaudisthebeast
    @houseofsaudisthebeast 7 дней назад

    4:33 an hamster born in an aquarium is a fish 🐹= 🐟

  • @ericbrown8479
    @ericbrown8479 7 дней назад

    Jamie was so blatantly wrong about Lyle when he wasn’t using ad hominems that I don’t see any point listening to any other podcasts you have him on. Basically I know he was wrong about Lyle so I can’t trust him about anyone else I don’t know if he’s even being truthful. And your lack of push back on him when you know Lyle and what Jaime is saying is wrong is just sad. But hey you get some views right?

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      I spoke with my other regular Craig about this today, and how sometimes Jamie says things that literally gob smack me whenever we're live. I mentioned how I didn't like the Lyle comments, and that I also didn't want to induce any vicarious cringe or awkwardness by calling a guest out on a live show. I mentioned it after hours that it wasn't cool and that Lyle is one of the few that I really respect and explained how he's a guy with impeccable integrity in this shitty industry. Understand if you don't want to listen but it's not going to stop our show or friendship. I also disagree with a lot of what Jamie says and I'm trying to get better at the pushback and counterargument,.but it's still one of my main weaknesses as a host and interviewer that I'm looking to improve Thanks for your feedback

  • @alexschutz7283
    @alexschutz7283 7 дней назад

    Was the Harvard study "Hypothesis: Vin Mariani is awesome! Experiment: drink a shit ton Conclusion: HolyshithaveyouheardaboutwhatthwRockefellersaregoingtodowiththatnewrailroadthing?openyoureyespeopleitsallabouttheadrenochrome! HUNNNNNNNGH! Dontworrythatwasjustalittleheartattackimfine. Thisshitsgreat!"

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      I wish society got back to doing some of those old time totally unethical dodgy studies. Now we gotta rely on tyrannical dictatorships to extend the boundaries of science with their total disregard to human safety and dignity 😂

    • @alexschutz7283
      @alexschutz7283 6 дней назад

      @@carvedouttastone lmao both options sound pretty similar when phrased that way

  • @andrewdavis6724
    @andrewdavis6724 7 дней назад

    Best one yet. You guys seem to be finding a natural flow to your discussions. Also: there’s a new sport out there. Car jujitsu. It’s kind of crazy watching people spar in cars.

    • @alexschutz7283
      @alexschutz7283 7 дней назад

      Like car to car? Or like 2 humans wrasslin in an extremely uncomfortable place (the backseat of a Volkswagen Beetle)? I would pay anything to see Harley jousting though. But it has to be people who already organically own Harleys

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      Thank you for saying we're improving. Hopefully we get even better with time - particularly when I adapt to keeping up with Jamie's sometimes wild takes. I'll check it out carjitsu - sounds like something Aussies would totally be inyi

    • @andrewdavis6724
      @andrewdavis6724 7 дней назад

      @@alexschutz7283 two people in a car not car to car

  • @stevepace-first8617
    @stevepace-first8617 8 дней назад

    Best English accent - South Yorkshire ( mine). Surveys say it is the most trusted of all UK dialects. It maintains old English biblical terms. You = thee. Your = thy. Tends to abbreviate and fully drop the definite article. I am going to the shop = Am gunna shop. It is not in the tin = tintintin. Form and function…I would also say health is further cornerstone which is not necessarily covered by the former and is relevant to PED use. No genetics…find that hard to swallow. Sure everyone can be good at something but not everyone can be good at any specified sport. I cannot see, for example, dwarves taking many gold medals apart from in those activities that do not discriminate in favour of the taller, and if that is the case, you could likely say the same about shorter athletes. Obviously there is a point where hard work may compensate but I doubt that some 4 foot six lad is going to be on many podiums. Not to say they cannot excel in some activity. Perhaps in many cases there is no absolute barrier to entry, but I would tend to think that those endowed with genetic gifts have a far easier time of it. Our friend Mike Mentzer was a big proponent of the genetic factor. I would tend to think just as there is variance in height largely down to genetic inheritance, there is variance in many other qualities, and all other factors being equal ( which they are not) the genetic advantage will prevail. Genetics and drugs might not be the alpha and omega, but neither are they insignificant. Absolutism is a poor guide here, we need a more dialectical perspective. ….Squatting 650 is easy, anyone can do anything….sounds off to me. Maybe if you believe in “the force” but back in the material world….

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 8 дней назад

      I'm in agreeance with your sentiments and it's why I'm sometimes hesitant to push back on certain viewpoints expressed by Jamie- simply because 1) I want to see where these thoughts are leading to and 2) like yourself I'm absolutist about nothing and want to ponder the cognitive dissonance I'm experiencing in the moment when something doesn't ring correct me with instead of reacting in instantaneous disagreement. I don't agree with some of the viewpoints such as "genetics don't matter", "drugs are irrelevant" "lifting doesn't have a science component". But at least these contentions challenge me to explore my own knowledge with a little more rigour than what a lot of social media is serving up these days. He may be wrong. He may be right, but he's definitely compelling either way. Thanks always for taking time to leave such thoughtful responses even though I don't always find the time to respond in kind. It's always valued and appreciated.

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 7 дней назад

      All good Shaun.

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 7 дней назад

      One area where I at least to some extent agree with JL is that there is a body size beyond which it is unwise to venture. Call it a natural limit of sorts, but once BMI goes so far, be it through blubber or muscle, the issues start to rack up. Massive pressure on knees, heavy breathing, sleep apnea….and it just starts looking awkward. He did not use to hold that view, but I think it is a mature perspective.

  • @DG-nb6fe
    @DG-nb6fe 8 дней назад

    First…

  • @stind1299
    @stind1299 8 дней назад

    If you can't get a Geneticist then an Evolutionary Biologist may be helpful. The question of genetics cannot be considered without taking into account evolution. Fitness for environment determine which genes move forward. Those innate traits, which help you survive your environment and persuade females to reproduce with you. Humans have adapted to various climates and situations such as warring tribes and so you get the different peoples around the world. Questions to pose. How much Genetic Diversity is there in the humans Species? What is the role of epigenetics in evolution? Is there an age where epigenetics generally happens more? (I'm guessing adolescent.) If you turn on dormant genes does that change your genetic sequence? Does that transfer to your offspring? The flea in jar experiment where fleas placed in jar jumped lower than they would normally to avoid banging their heads. Their offspring limited their jump heights to that of the jar. Seems to suggest tramsmission of survival knowledge via the genes. Unless I missed the point. If a person had child A before they got jacked and child B after they got jacked. Would child B inherit a greater propensity for being jacked? If this were the case and Child B gets Jacked. They have Child C. Would Child C have even higher potential for being jacked. Anedotal evidence. Lee Priest's mother was a bodybuilder. Did she have Lee before her exposure to weights or after? Frank Zane says that his father had a naturally good physique from just hard labour. Ronnie Coleman's mother! Environment I remember reading somewhere about a swim meet with swimmers competing in various rounds and the winners going forward to the final. At the final all swimmers had very similar bodies. Those bodies most suited for the swimming activity went through. Kinda like evolution in real time. How does that apply to bodybuilding? Bodybuilding used to prize various traits such as shapely muscles, thin skin and small joints. These combinations are good for bodybuilding but bad in other environments. Lee Haney kept breaking his legs when playing football due to small joints and Dorian Yates thin skin kept getting him bloodied in Martial arts. In certain environments they are champions but in other fields of little note.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 8 дней назад

      This is an amazing compilation of questions and discussion points and I thank you for taking the time to post that Stind. Any names you can suggest reaching out to. Getting guests is becoming more challenging as everyone seems to be "podcasted-out" in terms of their commitment to appearing. This is the only reason why I wish for better numbers on my view count - if the metrics don't measure up, people are less inclined to want to reply to requests.

    • @stind1299
      @stind1299 7 дней назад

      Bret Weinstein comes to mind. He does get involved in a lot of political stuff but may relish talking shop. I've thinking anout the positive health response that the Petersons and yourself have experienced from carnivore. You say that each person is a universe in themselves. I wonder if those who benefit have Genes that are a throwback to an earlier time, prior to the agrarian revolution. Perhaps some people are better adapted to the agrarian diet. Then again maybe everyone could benefit. Interesting.

  • @basilguts1786
    @basilguts1786 8 дней назад

    Wise head.

  • @samlee6749
    @samlee6749 8 дней назад

    The best way to move forward, is to look back. Very well said.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      Thank you. Hopefully you enjoyed the review. :-)

  • @medfly101
    @medfly101 8 дней назад

    Frankly Zane had one of the best looks. He was one of my favorite's. I know he wasn't massive but his look was just perfect.

    • @craigwinter458
      @craigwinter458 8 дней назад

      Yes, I would agree, in that Frank had a sensational overall look with beautiful flow and a masterclass in dramatic posing! 👍👌🤩

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      Definitely agree. I like how he didn't feel pressure to play the size and strength game. Carved out his own path and became an enduring icon for his look which has been imitated but never replicated

  • @Dee-ek6vk
    @Dee-ek6vk 8 дней назад

    Coward

  • @stevepace-first8617
    @stevepace-first8617 10 дней назад

    Sadly I never seem to catch the live episode, but one thing I would like to bring up for Jamie or anyone is his take on Doggcrapp /DC training. In part because Shaun has mentioned taking on Dorian style. I tend to think that this high intensity approach is optimal in one sense, fastest, most direct way to get the job done. But it is brutal, and is going to alienate the masses who do not want to go to the extreme end. Start talking about squats and deadlifts for high reps and the crowd disappears, taking their money with them. To me it seems that this endeavour is becoming ever more drug fuelled, perhaps in part because I live in the UK where roids are legal and widespread. But even so, this is not necessarily leading to massive muscularity. Of the millions on steroids, how many are training hard on the big lifts? I do not know, but I suspect that many are hopping on gear to avoid the hard work. On gear, everything works. Watch Netflix and grow to a certain extent at least, depending on response. I think this aspect, gear and genetics, including response to gear, is all part and parcel of the science vs art debate. Increasingly ( so it seems to me) the results are coming out of a lab. And when one considers professional bodybuilding, the evolution from say Reg Park to Nick Walker, this is evident. Admittedly I know little about the gear in its various aspects, I have not pursued that path, but I tend to think that minus that factor, then the subjective element of programming or simply going by feel is largely eliminated and the vast majority not blessed with any special genetic advantage have to work within a much narrower set of parameters/ principles to get anywhere beyond mediocre.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      I've always been an advocate of HIT/DC for the majority of my training life, but I've realized that it's a colour on the paint pallet. I feel HiT doesn't exist to the exclusion of other methods which also have their place and at times work better than HIT. Its a great system if you have the psychological predisposition for it (many don't) I love it for its time, energy and efficiency aspect - but it's inarguable that the majority of history's best physiques have been built via volume based programs.

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 7 дней назад

      @@carvedouttastone I think the same. I have tried a variety of approaches and as far as I know, the studies seem to suggest a few sets are better than one, but I think the scientific verification of all this over decades of training is in its infancy, so to a certain extent at least we are going on evaluation of the logic, plus the science as it is, incomplete. I think that the principles of HIT have to be adapted to the individual and all the various programmes are attempts to shoot a moving target. What interests me is how we do this for life. I have dabbled with various sports but they were just side adventures. The real deal for me is keeping going into old age. I was never attracted to the roids, getting massive, snap city poundages enough to take that route. It appeals to the ego, an immediate sense of self importance when the world does not offer much, a sort of grandiose compensation when reality is often adverse. I have come to the conclusion that plenty of cardio and a moderate amount of weights done hard works well for my goals, and DC fits, though I think various approaches could.

  • @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240
    @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240 10 дней назад

    Catgut is usually made from rumanant intestine. Cows,goats etc not cats. Not allot to work with

  • @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240
    @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240 10 дней назад

    Dorking hard! Ty Shawn, Jamie & Gretta

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      You're welcome mate and thanks for giving this episode a chance because I think there was some fun and educational discussion to be had here

    • @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240
      @vancouvercomedyuncensoredv8240 7 дней назад

      ​@@carvedouttastone There's an audience!

  • @The1stHannibal-ex5fo
    @The1stHannibal-ex5fo 10 дней назад

    He's an chameleon

  • @BasilMasters
    @BasilMasters 10 дней назад

    I'm glad Mike Mentzer Beat up Arnold! Mentzer was robbed of the Mr. Olympia that year.

  • @WhyAreTheyOverHere
    @WhyAreTheyOverHere 10 дней назад

    Gay man. Gay "sport".

  • @stind1299
    @stind1299 10 дней назад

    Your conversations are a gold mine of nuggets to consider. Not even a third of the way through. I may well be barking up the wrong tree. The discussion of whether Bodybuilding is an Art or Science has points on both sides, but I would say that Bodybuilding is a Technology. The use of technology predates science. Just as the body of Bodybuilding knowledge comes from history rather than Science. Technology is a broad concept that deals with a species' usage and knowledge of tools .... affects a species' ability to control and adapt to its environment. A popular defintion. Barbells, Dumbell, Indian Clubs and rocks are the tools in Bodybuilding. Science is knowing, but technology is about doing. I can understand Jamie's frustration with Science, although I'm inclined to agree on Lyle on intuition. Often we can't articulate the instincts. A deeper form of intelligence. We know from our gut and that's enough in many cases. Tom Platz is the best example of an intelligent bodybuilder that relied on instincts. Later on when working with Fred Hatfield, he could appreciate the science behind some of his practices such as the stretching he did. He did it because it felt good.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 8 дней назад

      Brilliant observations. Your comments are always worth their weight in gold. They encourage and educate me continually and I'm so grateful to have your participation in this channel's content. Can I ask your thoughts on an unrelated topic regarding Conan - the speech he makes

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 8 дней назад

      The famous speech he makes in reply to the question "what is best in life?" I know it's a bastardized version of (perhaps) Genghis Khan, but it seemed odd and out of character that he quotes this at this juncture of the movie He's been a slave and pit fighter for most of his life. He was then sent to the East to study and learn from those masters in that region - but he hasn't yet "lived" in any experiential-sense yet. He hasn't fought in battles, driven away any enemies, and as for the joy in listening to the "Lamentations of the women" - it seems out of character because he witnessed his mother's death by those very same bastards he vows for revenge on. He also seems quite compassionate to the women he is "given" in this early part of the movie. Do you have any thoughts or takes on this? Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but it's such a landmark scene and Millius so deliberate in his writing and character portrayal that it seems a little contradictory from my cursory viewing

    • @stind1299
      @stind1299 8 дней назад

      Praise from Caesar is high praise indeed. I'm honoured to be asked. I agree it is a powerful speech and much quoted. At the heart of this film I think is the search for a father that he lost. Throughout the film there are men that fulfill that role. He is parroting what they have taught him as War Masters and they have no tolerance for dissension. Shown in the rigid way he is schooled. He is a dangerous and obedient pet to them. He is exposed to many father figures and Thusa Doom even proclaims himself as his father at one point. From a mythic perspective Father is culture. Culture protects us from the wilderness and chaos.Without a father you are abandoned. Competing pathways that he could take. At the end of the film he becomes his own man after much reflection and the death of the revenge that drove him. It is a beautiful and Symbolic scene. No one could be a man unless his father has died.- Freud. Yes, but that death could occur symbolically. - Jung.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      Great take and thanks for relating as I thought that the speech had more meaning other than just "sounding-cool" in its deliberate inclusion to that scene Yes, the whole "father motif" is prominent in so many of Oliver Stone's older films that he was criticised as being a one trick pony when it came to his thematic approach to script writing. As you're probably aware, Stone wrote the original script for Conan which Millius subsequently gutted and rewrote, but Stone got a writing credit because enough of his material and concepts were salvageable - the father motif im guessing as being one of those concepts I also think the Thulsa Doom father quip was a nice troll alluding to the Darth Vader quote about being Luke's father - a cliffhanger that audiences back in 1982 were still awaiting the resolution of :-) I picked up on the Odepial references to the loss his mother - her replacement with Valeria and then the repeated loss again of this strong- warrior mother figure in his life. His decapitation of the "father figure" Doom with his father's broke blade as the squaring of this circle

    • @stind1299
      @stind1299 7 дней назад

      You bring such incredible depth to your work. Everything is thoroughly researched and thought about deeply particularly the context. I look forward to your enlightening review. Excellence is never an accident. It is always the result of high intention, sincere effort, and intelligent execution; it represents the wise choice of many alternatives - choice, not chance, determines your destiny. Aristotle

  • @johnconner1061
    @johnconner1061 11 дней назад

    Hang in there Shawn , Your hard work is appreciated.. 👊

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone 7 дней назад

      Cheers man - and sorry for the rant but I've realized the mental pressure of doing this RUclips game which I never realized before. Im not naturally creative or gifted in writing etc, so these things weigh heavily and constantly on my mind and it's hard to detach from the ever continuous content grind just to stay in the game. Really appreciate your support and thanks as always for watching

  • @rockyrocamontes8972
    @rockyrocamontes8972 11 дней назад

    I haven't seen any proof of these allegations.

  • @cadillacman2141
    @cadillacman2141 11 дней назад

    Today would have been a different story

  • @GG-wg1yh
    @GG-wg1yh 11 дней назад

    Nothing like listening to a bald fuck who looks like smeagol. Talk about someone using methamphetamines when he looks like he's been using crack cocaine since day one.

  • @MasterDavidAaronWarrington
    @MasterDavidAaronWarrington 11 дней назад

    As a young man I loved bodybuilding as much as anybody and came very close to using steroids. I never used the drugs and now I am 52 and still in pretty good shape! It's affirming to hear these stories about the truth of what my old heroes used to do to attain their Mass. Back in the 90s no one ever told the truth. Staying natural I'm in better shape than everybody else I know. If I had followed this path who knows if I would even still be alive. External alchemy shortens the lifespan.